A California woman leading a double life as an OnlyFans model and escort has admitted to killing a 55-year-old man during a sexual encounter that turned fatal. Michaela Rylaarsdam, 32, pleaded guilty on Wednesday, May 6, to causing the death of Michael Dale in 2023.
Prosecutors stated that videos from Rylaarsdam's phone showed Dale with his wrists tied, duct tape over his mouth, and a plastic bag covering his head for several minutes. She called 911, but Dale died the next day from asphyxiation due to the items placed over his head.
At the time of her arrest in February 2025, Rylaarsdam charged up to $1,500 plus a tip for her services, according to her website. Dale paid over $11,000 for the encounter and requested specific acts, including being tied up, wrapped in Saran Wrap, and having boots glued to his feet.
Rylaarsdam's husband, Brandon, allegedly knew about her secret life and helped run the business. The couple has three young children. On her escort page, she described herself as an upscale and classy creation with 10 years of experience, catering to men, women, and non-binary clients.
Police reported that Rylaarsdam claimed it was her first fetish encounter. However, disturbing video showed Dale inside a bag for about eight minutes, struggling to breathe. His arms and legs were bound, preventing him from removing the wrappings. As he lay unresponsive, Rylaarsdam performed a sex act nearby for her OnlyFans page, prosecutors alleged.
Rylaarsdam initially pleaded not guilty to second-degree murder. Her attorney, Dan Cohen, argued that there was no intent to kill and that Dale consented to the acts. He also questioned the cause of death, noting that Dale had alcohol and prescription drugs in his system.
Rylaarsdam faces sentencing for the charge, with the court considering the circumstances of the case.
