British football analyst Geoff Shreeves has sparked controversy by demanding that Portugal manager Roberto Martinez exclude legendary striker Cristiano Ronaldo from the national team's starting lineup. This bold recommendation follows Portugal's mixed performances in recent 2026 FIFA World Cup qualifiers.
The Case Against Ronaldo
The debate intensified after Portugal suffered a shocking 2-0 defeat to Ireland on November 13, where the 40-year-old Manchester United legend received a red card during the match. However, in Ronaldo's absence, Portugal delivered a spectacular 9-1 victory against Armenia in their final qualification game.
Shreeves, a respected British football pundit, explained his position through a viral social media post. He argued that Ronaldo's presence negatively impacts Portugal's team dynamics, particularly their pressing game and overall mobility.
Technical Limitations Cited
"Portugal are a pressing team, and Cristiano Ronaldo cannot press, because he doesn't have the legs," Shreeves stated emphatically. The pundit referenced Portugal's 2022 World Cup campaign in Qatar, where then-coach Fernando Santos benched Ronaldo in favor of Goncalo Ramos, who responded with an impressive hat-trick.
Despite Ronaldo's recent success in guiding Portugal to victory in the 2025 UEFA Nations Cup against Spain, winning 5-3 via penalty shootout after a 2-2 draw in regulation time, Shreeves believes the team functions better without their veteran star. Ronaldo's statistical record remains impressive with 143 goals and 46 assists in 226 appearances across all competitions according to Sofascore.
Fan Reactions and Counterarguments
The football community has responded passionately to Shreeves' comments. One supporter, @Chidoskinho, questioned the double standard: "If CR7 does not press.. Does Messi press? Being the best comes with huge hatred."
Another fan, @0xMcEal, defended Ronaldo's legacy: "Everyone wants a piece of the CR7 cake. Where was Ramos when they lost to Morocco? That same CR7 helped equalize against Spain to win the EUROs."
@Kamblossi added to the counterargument: "That pressing argument is so old and tired. Was Messi pressing when they won the world cup? Has he ever pressed even in any of the teams he has played at? I promise you football is not all about pressing."
Shreeves did acknowledge that Ronaldo could still contribute from the bench, recognizing his massive aura and personality. However, he maintained that Portugal appears more fluid and mobile without the Al Nassr star in the starting eleven.
As Ronaldo aims to win the 2026 FIFA World Cup before retiring from international football, having secured all other available trophies, this debate continues to divide football experts and fans alike. The decision ultimately rests with manager Roberto Martinez, who must balance legendary experience against tactical requirements.
