Manchester United Set to Overlook Carrick for Permanent Managerial Role
In a surprising development at Old Trafford, Manchester United's hierarchy appears poised to pass over interim manager Michael Carrick for the permanent coaching position. Despite Carrick's impressive unbeaten streak since taking charge in January 2026, the club's board is reportedly focusing their search elsewhere.
Carrick's Interim Success Fails to Secure Permanent Position
The 44-year-old former England international has achieved remarkable results during his brief tenure, guiding the Red Devils to four consecutive victories and one draw. Under Carrick's leadership, Manchester United became the only Premier League club to remain undefeated throughout 2026, climbing into the top four positions within just two months.
Carrick's most notable achievement came at London Stadium, where his tactical substitutions proved decisive. With West Ham leading until the final moments, substitute Benjamin Sesko scored in the 96th minute, assisted by Cameroonian winger Bryan Mbueno, to salvage a crucial point for United.
The interim manager also ended Manchester United's eight-match winless streak against Tottenham and secured victories over title contenders Arsenal and Manchester City. Despite these accomplishments, the club's decision-makers remain unconvinced about Carrick's long-term suitability.
United's Board Seeks Proven Trophy Winner
According to reports from the Manchester Evening News, Manchester United's ownership, including Sir Jim Ratcliffe, prioritizes appointing a manager with demonstrated success in winning major trophies and sustaining competitive excellence over multiple seasons. This strategic direction has led the club to consider more experienced candidates.
Sky Sports sources indicate that former Chelsea manager Thomas Tuchel has emerged as a leading contender for the position. The German tactician currently manages England's national team and is contracted to lead the Three Lions through the 2026 FIFA World Cup, with his agreement set to expire following the tournament.
Tuchel's credentials include guiding Chelsea to the 2021 UEFA Champions League title and winning multiple league championships in both France and Germany. His reputation for implementing disciplined tactical systems and achieving immediate success aligns with Manchester United's stated requirements.
Fan Reactions and Alternative Candidates
Manchester United supporters have expressed mixed reactions to the potential managerial change. Social media platforms reveal divided opinions among the fanbase:
- @Oluwagbemiga_7p commented: "Just because of a draw, being Manchester United manager is no joke. All the other big six sides don't face this level of scrutiny."
- @BorzUnited wrote: "Tuchel to Man United? Either he brings the discipline to dominate the league, or Old Trafford faces turmoil. The Premier League isn't ready for this combination."
- @Jesse_K_Zoaka added: "Bringing in someone with a different philosophy than Carrick would be a setback. He has built a cohesive team quickly, suggesting he could create something formidable over time."
Meanwhile, Dutch football legend Ruud Gullit has suggested another potential candidate, publicly endorsing former United striker Robin van Persie for a future managerial role at the club. Van Persie, who played a crucial role in Manchester United's last Premier League title victory in 2013, remains highly regarded at Old Trafford.
The managerial decision comes following Ruben Amorim's dismissal in January, which created the interim opportunity that Carrick has utilized to demonstrate his capabilities. As Manchester United continues their pursuit of returning to championship contention, the choice of permanent manager will significantly impact the club's direction for coming seasons.
