In a fiery television debate, former Manchester United captain Roy Keane has emphatically stated that Michael Carrick should not be appointed as the club's permanent manager, regardless of his impressive interim results. Keane made these controversial remarks on Sky Sports following Manchester United's thrilling 3–2 victory over Arsenal at the Emirates Stadium on Sunday.
Keane's Unwavering Stance on Carrick's Future
Despite Carrick's remarkable start as interim boss, which includes wins over top teams managed by Pep Guardiola, Mikel Arteta, Unai Emery, and Thomas Tuchel, Keane remains unconvinced. When asked by Micah Richards if Carrick should now be considered for the full-time role, Keane dismissed the idea outright.
"No, you're being silly now," Keane declared. "He's had two great performances but anybody can win two games. It's what he does until the end of the season and even if they do get into fourth I still wouldn't be convinced he's the man for the job, absolutely not."
Even Flawless Results Would Not Change Keane's Mind
Keane went further, insisting that a perfect run of victories would not alter his opinion. "I think if United win every game from now until the end of the season, I still wouldn't be giving him the job," he said. "I just think they need a bigger, more experienced manager, it's as simple as that."
He acknowledged Carrick's current success but questioned its sustainability. "Carrick could win every game. The timing coming into the job is fantastic for him. And he said it there, he's enjoying it, but you're enjoying management when you're winning football matches, of course."
Manchester United's Recent Form Under Carrick
Manchester United's win over Arsenal featured a dramatic comeback, with goals from Patrick Dorgu and Matheus Cunha securing victory after Bryan Mbeumo had equalized earlier. This result followed a previous triumph over Manchester City, positioning United strongly in the league standings.
Long-Term Demands and Club Size Concerns
Keane expressed doubts about Carrick's ability to meet the long-term challenges at Old Trafford. "The size of the club and the challenges they will face over the next few years… you want a manager who you feel can come in and get United winning league titles," he explained.
"Are we all going to sit here and believe Michael Carrick can get United winning league titles? The last two weeks are not enough for me. If you think off the back of two wins he warrants the job then that's your opinion and I'm entitled to mine and I don't believe he is the man to get United back to winning league titles."
Diverging Opinions in the Debate
Former Arsenal captain Patrick Vieira offered a contrasting view, arguing that Carrick deserves an opportunity. "I think you have young managers with no experience who deserve to have a chance," Vieira said, citing examples of successful first-time managers in European football.
Keane rejected this comparison, noting: "There's loads of examples of young managers getting opportunities and doing really well. But there's more examples of managers getting jobs and not doing well."
Gary Neville's Measured Perspective
Gary Neville provided a more balanced take, praising Carrick's impact while suggesting caution. He remarked that Carrick's football had made him feel like he had "got his club back," but advised the board to still seek an elite, experienced coach at season's end. Keane, however, challenged Neville's praise, continuing the animated exchange on air.
Interim Role and Future Plans
Michael Carrick is expected to remain in interim charge until the end of the season, mirroring the temporary role previously held by Ralf Rangnick. Meanwhile, Manchester United continues its search for a permanent head coach, with Keane's comments adding fuel to the ongoing debate about the club's managerial direction.
